How Do We Educate Students in a way that is not Tech Tool Specific?

The announcement, this week, that Aviary will close its advanced suite on September 15, prompted me to think about bigger questions in educational technology. For those who don’t know, Aviary’s advanced suite was a powerful collection of free image and audio editing web tools. We all get excited about a good app – myself included- but this announcement got me thinking. At his excellent blog, Richard Byrne said he could not initially think of any suggestions of replacement apps, and that is with his encyclopedic knowledge of educational technology.

So, how do we educate students in a way that is not tool specific? This is not the first or last time something we use will disappear. If we are not teaching specific tools, what are our real goals?

Some of the commenters on the post from Freetech4teachers said they were disappointed because they planned on using the Aviary suite with students this year. Another person said it best, “change is inevitable.” One of the only disadvantages to cloud-based computing for users is that things can and will just disappear. With local software, once it is installed, you can continue to use it even if the developers stop supporting it.

Students need to be able to read write and discuss things only in a respectful way. Students need to be able to navigate the web with a critical eye, evaluating web pages for safety and relevance. Students also need to be independent in the same way we want them to be for research projects; they need to know where to find tools and how to choose the best ones to fit their needs. We need web-savvy students.

I am one of those disappointed educators who was looking forward to trying these tools out with my students this year. But, this served as a good reminder that in the upcoming school year that I need to help kids become tech-savvy rather than app experts.


NBC Fails to Innovate for this Year’s Olympic Games

By iwillbehomesoon via Flickr (CC license)

The 2012 Summer Olympic Games in London presented a challenging situation for the NBC television network. Although internet news and social networking were prevalent during the 2008 Games in Beijing, they were not as widespread and nowhere near as mobile as in 2012. Smart phones and tablets have people not only connected in every place they go, but even in between everywhere they go. Just to give you an idea of the influence of one network, Twitter, in 2008, 100 million tweets were sent per quarter. In 2010 there were 50 million tweets per day. So far, 2012 numbers show 340 million tweets per day (The Daily Telegraph and Twitter Engineering Team via Wikipedia). The current situation facing NBC and US Olympic fans is that all of our daily news sources are reporting results of events as they happen live. This news is also spreading across social networks. NBC has decided to restrict access and delaying coverage of the most popular events for primetime television.

My girlfriend is most looking forward to watching the swimming and gymnastics events, and we planned on watching the first men’s swimming final last night, on NBC. Unfortunately, she accidentally learned of the results of the race from a push notification from the CNN iPhone app in the late morning. She was not happy, but she wouldn’t tell me the results, as to not ruin the surprise for anyone else. Then, a few hours later as I absentmindedly checked into Twitter on my phone, there was a headline from The Daily Beast, Phelps Dethroned. At this point, I thought, I might as well read the details. Although swimming is not my favorite to watch, I was frustrated by the experience, because I imagined this happening on the days I plan to watch track and field.

Not only is NBC delaying coverage of events, it’s live website coverage is problematic as well. If your personal schedule does not allow you to watch events live, you can watch “all events online” as the NBC website states. However, the most popular events, those slated for prime time television spots, are blocked out from the list of available replays. When I went to watch live events, the problems continued. You need to sign in with your account from your cable provider. Isn’t NBC a national network which is broadcast for free over the air? Ok, now I am starting to see their confusion. NBC is suffering from a bit of an identity crisis.

So, I sign in to my Comcast account and I get this message from Comcast/Xfinity, “This service is not included in your current subscription.” Sure it is. NBC is included in my basic TV package everyday. The message goes on to explain how I need the digital starter package to view this content online…at the NBC website. Now, I’m getting confused. And I’m not even sure who to be upset with at this point (mostly at myself for wasting so much of my time and energy on this).

This is just unabashedly greedy. They are betting that we are going to look past all of this obvious manipulation and sit in front of the TV for three hours waiting for the men’s swimming finals when we already know that Michael Phelps lost – in fact, we’ve known since early this morning. They want to drive ratings, by herding everyone to the evening TV coverage. By doing that they can make more money from the advertisers. The London opening ceremonies on Friday night had higher ratings than any other opening ceremonies (The Daily Beast). Will they be able to sustain that over the next two weeks?

Of course there has been a huge backlash online from NBC viewers by the lack of access to live events. In response, an NBC spokesman told the Wall Street Journal, “They are complex entertainment spectacles that do not translate well online because they require context.” Do we get that context from our expert commentators? Is that like during the opening ceremonies when one person mentioned the spectacular system of lights around the audience, and Meredith Vieira stated, “That is one more thing I don’t understand.”? Thanks for the vital context NBC.

If NBC and other large television organizations want to survive they must think of themselves as media organizations, not television networks. This was a remarkable opportunity for NBC to come up with an innovative solution using the full scope of their media resources. Instead they defaulted to an old model of TV coverage as TechCrunch put it.

The major American networks already survived the biggest technological transition in the past decade, from radio to television. This change involved a massive shift in infrastructure and the way information is delivered, involving primarily visual storytelling. What makes their current situation markedly more difficult, is that the world is changing much faster. In the early 20th century, the networks dictated the change. Now there are too many players and too much open access to media and information. Can they make that switch again?

As an iPad user, I discovered that I could not watch the NBC content in the web browser. So, I reluctantly installed NBC’s sad attempts at apps. The video app also requires sign-in from your cable provider. Not only was the UI clunky and haphazardly design, I was still blocked from watching any events. It seems that mobile was an afterthought. Too bad mobile is no longer the future, but the reality of the present.

US fans are left in quite a predicament in the next two weeks. Do we completely disconnect ourselves from our social and information networks? Turn off all notifications? Stop logging in to our favorite services? Doubtful. When was the last time you did that for more than an eight hour sleep?
Will we be able to enjoy watching the prerecorded broadcasts having already learned the results?

NBC’s approach to this year’s olympic games is just foolish. It could signal the end of an era.

During last night’s TV coverage, the commentators were discussing an olympian who reportedly signed out of all of his social networks, effectively unplugged during the days leading up to competition. The purpose was to be completely focused on his performance without distraction (many of us know what a gift and a curse technology can be). Then one of the commentators said, “That is a big deal,” with a tinge of smug sarcasm. That is the same attitude, I imagine, of the NBC executives and other leaders who have let this year’s coverage become such a mess.

On my last visit to the website to try streaming the events, the NBC Olympics web page had a story about how Michael phelps had been defeated, before the event had even aired on TV.

Update: Another reason that I want true live coverage is so I do not miss interesting, moving performances that someone else decided I would not like to see. Well, I would like to see it. Just learned about this Sunday night.

Celebrating My First Month Blogging!

It has been one month since I started this blog and it has already grown and expanded. I enjoy learning from the process as well. I still feel energized and motivated by the many visitors, “likers” and especially my first few followers. Although I can’t thank you with a monetary gift like DropBox did this month with many of their early adopters, I can reward with shout outs.

Check out these great blogs from cool people!




Christopher Vennard

One subscriber via RSS that I know about:

Looking at my stats from the past week or so has been very exciting. This was the first week where I had visitors to the site everyday, even when I did not post!

To continue the celebration, here are a few of the most popular and personal favorite posts of the month:

My first Must Read Weekly List

Photo, Notre Dame

When Something Goes Wrong, We Stop Dead

Photo, Eiffel Tower

Do Customer Service Call Centers Ever Cheat?

Reading List: DIY Social Network, Hidden Profits, Flame Retardants, Who is Really in Control?

This is my weekly list of what I most want to share. What have I read that was fascinating, exciting, puzzling, or inspiring. Catch up on some things you missed from the past week. Maybe I dug up a few obscure gems that are totally new to you. Check out the brief ones now and save the more lengthy ones for later. Share and be share to…here’s the list:

F. Scott Fitzgerald’s letter to a young writer. Hard words to hear, but good advice. Via the “Letter’s of Note” blog.

Apple’s hidden profits: billions tucked away for taxes it may never pay. Very interesting read from The Washington Post. You decide whether or not what they are doing is fair or ethical.

Flame Retardant Chemicals. Via the EWG. Its about time our government took notice of this important safety and environmental issue.

Excellent dissection of the service Facebook provides and alternative companies that just do some things better. This is one I wish i wrote. Via “LifeHacker.”

Watch This

News reel footage of the Olympics from Italy – not sure what year – maybe 1950s.

Long reads

Amazing essay on innovation and how we have trouble getting big stuff done. Via

Who is really in control of America’s farmland? Much of the focus of the article is on Missouri, but these are nationwide issues. Via The Nation.

The changing landscape of hiring is disenfranchising workers. A wonderful, indepth, and scathing piece from Mother Jones.

“My hometown is vibrant.” How a meaningless buzzword of urban development isnt producing meaningful results. Strikes an impressive balance between satire and informative reporting. Via The Baffler.

Birds on the Beach

After a month of traveling to Europe and the US Northeast, I am back home in sunny Florida. To celebrate my homecoming, here is a shot of a beautiful bird that we have only seen this one time. This was taken at Lover’s Key State Park near Fort Myers.

Taken at Lover’s Key State Park in Florida

Model: Nikon D40     Shutter: 1/500     Apeture: f/11.0     Focal Length: 55mm     ISO: 200

Each Wednesday, I publish an original photo along with some of the technical information. You can see more of my photography on my Flickr page.

My photography is licensed under Creative Commons (see details below). In addition, I ask that if you use any of my images that you try to show me how you used them. I think it would be interesting to see and track how my images are being used. Thank you.

Creative Commons LicenseThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.